Skip to main content

⛓️ Top-Down vs Bottom-Up: The Direction That Builds Your Tree

Build direction isn’t just about performance — it’s a design constraint.

Whether you're parsing JSON into a tree, hashing leaves into a Merkle root, or streaming a hierarchy from an API, the choice between top-down and bottom-up shapes how you structure your data and code.

🔃 Build Direction: What It Means​

DirectionDescriptionCommon Use CasesConstraint
Top-DownStart from the root and add childrenFile systems, UI trees, parent-first API responsesYou must know the root(s) or have all parents before children
Bottom-UpStart with children and assign them to their parentMerkle trees, expression trees, compilersEach child must know its parent ID or path

❓ Does Parent Need to Come Before Child?​

That depends on your build strategy:

✅ Map-Based Builds (No Order Required)​

index = {node["id"]: node for node in flat_list}
for node in flat_list:
    parent = index.get(node["parent_id"])
    if parent:
        parent.setdefault("children", []).append(node)

You build an index first, then link everything — order doesn’t matter.

⚠️ Recursive or Streaming Builds (Order Matters)​

  • Top-down: Must see the parent before its children.
  • Bottom-up: Must have all children before processing the parent.

🧠 Example: Merkle Tree (Bottom-Up)​

import hashlib

def hash_node(left, right):
    return hashlib.sha256((left + right).encode()).hexdigest()

leaves = ['a', 'b', 'c', 'd']
hashed = [hashlib.sha256(leaf.encode()).hexdigest() for leaf in leaves]

while len(hashed) > 1:
    if len(hashed) % 2 == 1:
        hashed.append(hashed[-1])  # duplicate if odd
    hashed = [hash_node(hashed[i], hashed[i + 1]) for i in range(0, len(hashed), 2)]

print(f"Merkle root: {hashed[0]}")

✅ You can’t build this top-down — the root depends entirely on the children.

🧭 When to Choose Top-Down​

Use a top-down strategy when:

  • You want to build from a starting point and assign children as you go

  • The data arrives parent-first or is structured as a hierarchy

  • You're constructing interactive or visual hierarchies (menus, org charts, DOM trees)

  • The root is either:

    • Explicitly defined (e.g., parent_id = null)
    • Chosen arbitrarily from data you control (e.g., in binary search trees)

⚠️ In many cases, you can choose any item to be the root, especially in structures like binary trees. But once you pick a root, your direction is locked in — you're now building top-down.

def build_tree_top_down(node, data_by_parent):
    children = data_by_parent.get(node["id"], [])
    node["children"] = [build_tree_top_down(child, data_by_parent) for child in children]
    return node

🧭 When to Choose Bottom-Up​

Use bottom-up when:

  • Each node contains data that must be processed or combined before building parents
  • You're building trees like Merkle, expression, or abstract syntax trees (ASTs)
  • You want the structure to emerge from leaf data, not be imposed from above

🔍 This is common in compiler design, hashing structures, and scoring trees — where the parent’s value depends on its children.

def combine_scores(scores):
    while len(scores) > 1:
        scores = [scores[i] + scores[i+1] for i in range(0, len(scores), 2)]
    return scores[0]

🔁 Bonus: Hybrid Strategies​

In practice, many systems use a hybrid:

  • Step 1: Index all nodes (bottom-up preparation)
  • Step 2: Walk from root(s) (top-down construction)

This avoids order requirements during ingestion while still producing a usable tree.

🧩 Summary​

Use CaseStrategy
UI trees / menusTop-down
Hashing / scoring / aggregationBottom-up
Parsing deeply nested expressionsBottom-up
Streaming data (parent before child)Top-down
Streaming data (unordered)Index-based

📚 Related Reads​

This article is part of a series on building and working with trees: